Its been a bad weekend for the amusement industry. First, an incident on Friday evening at Cedar Point's Shoot the Rapids ride resulted in several minor injuries, with one guest treated and later released from a local hospital. Luckily, all indications at this point in time are that this incident looked worse than it actually was. Unfortunately, the same can not be said for the incident at Six Flags Over Texas, occurring just a couple of hours later, that tragically ended the life of Rosy Esparza after a fall from The Texas Giant roller coaster. Understandably, these incidents, particularly the death of Ms. Esparza, have garnered a huge amount of attention from the local and national media, not to mention social media, over the last 36 hours. That's to be expected when an event like this occurs. Over the next few days, there will be a plethora of media reports, tweets, Facebook posts, and editorials opining about what happened in Texas, how it could have been prevented, and what is "wrong" with the amusement industry that such an event could occur. In the midst of this maelstrom, I think it's important to keep some perspective and to keep a few things in mind so that the important work ahead of us can get done and get done right:About Me
- Erik H. Beard, Esq.
- I am a consultant and general counsel to International Ride Training LLC as well as a practicing attorney in Avon, Connecticut. A particular focus of mine is the legal needs of the amusement and tourism industry. My focus on the amusement industry derives from my pre-law career as an operations manager with Cedar Fair Entertainment Company and Universal Orlando. Having started my career as a ride operator at Cedar Point in 1992, I progressed through the seasonal ranks and ultimately became the Manager of Ride Operations and Park Services at Worlds of Fun in Kansas City. I also worked in Universal's operations department during the construction and development of Islands of Adventure. Today, I am an active member of the New England Association of Amusement Parks & Attractions and the International Association of Amusement Parks & Attractions. I have been invited to speak at amusement industry meetings and seminars and have worked on a variety of matters relating to this industry.
Legal Disclaimer (because, you know, I'm a lawyer)
This Blog/Web Site is made available for educational purposes only as well as to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice (or any legal advice). By using this blog site you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and the Blog/Web Site publisher and / or author nor can such a relationship be created by use of his Blog / Web Site. By using thisBlog / Web Site you understand that any statement on the blog site are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of Wiggin and Dana LLP or International Ride Training LLC. By using this blog site you understand that the Blog/Web Site is not affiliated with or approved by Wiggin and Dana LLP or International Ride Training LLC. The Blog/Web Site should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state or jurisdiction. This blog is not published for advertising or solicitation purposes. Regardless, the hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements.
Sunday, July 21, 2013
Special Report - Tragedy On The Texas Giant: A Call For Focus Amid Distraction
Its been a bad weekend for the amusement industry. First, an incident on Friday evening at Cedar Point's Shoot the Rapids ride resulted in several minor injuries, with one guest treated and later released from a local hospital. Luckily, all indications at this point in time are that this incident looked worse than it actually was. Unfortunately, the same can not be said for the incident at Six Flags Over Texas, occurring just a couple of hours later, that tragically ended the life of Rosy Esparza after a fall from The Texas Giant roller coaster. Understandably, these incidents, particularly the death of Ms. Esparza, have garnered a huge amount of attention from the local and national media, not to mention social media, over the last 36 hours. That's to be expected when an event like this occurs. Over the next few days, there will be a plethora of media reports, tweets, Facebook posts, and editorials opining about what happened in Texas, how it could have been prevented, and what is "wrong" with the amusement industry that such an event could occur. In the midst of this maelstrom, I think it's important to keep some perspective and to keep a few things in mind so that the important work ahead of us can get done and get done right:Friday, July 19, 2013
Planes, Trains, & Waterslides? Missouri Imposes Heightened Liability Standard On Amusement And Water Parks
The Missouri Court of Appeals this week issued a stunning
decision in Chavez v. Cedar Fair L.P.
holding that a water slide operator (or, in that case, a family raft ride
operator) owes the same duty of care as a so-called “common carrier,” i.e.
operators of mass transportation – airplanes, trains, ships, etc., to safeguard
guest safety. In so holding, Missouri has
become the first state in the country to impose this heightened standard of
liability on water park operators. The
Court’s analysis is fundamentally flawed both in its application to the
allegations in this case and in providing guidance to future courts in future
cases. Even accepting the Court’s
suspect legal analysis, the result ignores the plaintiff’s own allegations of
liability – allegations which should have resulted in a lower standard of care
than that which the Court imposed.
Moreover, and more importantly, the Court failed to undertake the case-by-case
analysis the court claims is required to reach the result it did, thus sending
the wrong message to future courts. If
permitted to stand, this decision will increase liability exposure to Missouri amusement
operators (both water park and otherwise) and sets a dangerous precedent for amusement
industry cases filed in other jurisdictions.
More on all of this after the jump.**
Wednesday, May 1, 2013
New Study Confirms That Children Are Safe On Amusement Rides (You Didn't Hear?)
So, did you hear about the new amusement ride safety report published today in the journal Clinical Pediatrics that actually demonstrates scientifically that amusement ride injuries to children under the age of 17 are exceptionally rare? How about the scientific study that shows that amusement ride related injuries to this population dropped by an estimated 50% between 1991 and 2003? Well, surely you must have seen the study, which received institutional review board approval at The Research Institute at Nationwide Children's Hospital, showing that, of those extremely few guests under the age of 17 that are injured on amusement rides, 97.8% are either treated and released or examined and released without treatment? No? You didn't see that either? Yeah ... me neither. But here's what I did see today:
Friday, April 12, 2013
A Response To Consumers Digest's Waterslide Safety Report (a belated Part 2): Federal Oversight Is No Answer
My last post was a response to a recent article in Consumers
Digest magazine that suggested that waterpark injuries were on a sharp rise and
that the best solution to solving that problem was implementing new federal
regulation that would require reporting of waterpark injuries to federal
authorities. My initial response took on
the factual underpinnings of this article, showing that even the very
injury-data Consumers Digest relied upon failed to support the central thesis
that waterparks were dangerous and becoming more so. Now it’s time for the second issue raised both
in the Consumers Digest piece and, more generally, in the media every time an
unfortunate incident occurs: Is federal
regulation the answer?
Monday, March 4, 2013
A Response To Consumers Digest's Waterslide Safety Report (Part 1): The Numbers Don't Lie
A story was published today in Consumers Digest entitled “Waterparks: Is Public Safety Going Down the Tubes” that
paints an extremely unflattering and misleading picture of the safety of the waterpark
industry as a whole. Authored by Sara
Bongiorni, the piece makes a number of disturbing assertions to suggest that injuries
at waterparks in the United States are increasing at an alarming rate and that
the best solution to countering this trend is federal regulation of the fixed
site amusement industry. The piece takes
great issue with the so-called “patchwork” of state regulations governing the amusement
industry and even goes so far as to portray the industry as expending hundreds
of thousands of dollars per year specifically to avoid federal regulation. I’ve seen other pieces like this – usually in
the wake of a tragic accident at a park or carnival. Rarely, though, have I seen a piece that goes
to the extent that this piece does in mis-characterizing the facts and ignoring
gaping holes in the logic and reasoning underlying its conclusions. I thus feel compelled to address some of the
more troubling aspects of Ms. Bongiorni’s piece. The article though is rather lengthy, so I
thought the best way to address it was in two parts. Today, I’ll discuss the problems with Ms.
Bongiorni’s injury statistics, and how they were manipulated to paint a far direr
picture than exists in reality. In Part
2, I’ll address her contention that federal regulation is the answer to all the
industry’s problems.
Tuesday, February 26, 2013
He Said / She Said: A Conversation About The ADA’s Applicability To The Amusement Industry

Given her background and experience, I
was very interested to get her take on the recent lawsuits and the ADA’s
application to the amusement industry.
Our conversation raised some interesting issues that I thought would be
worthwhile to share.
Labels:
ADA,
assumption of risk,
Ault,
Baughman,
Darien Lake,
disability,
discrimination,
legislation,
litigation,
litigation settlement,
public interest,
regulation,
ride accident,
ride incident
Tuesday, January 15, 2013
New ADA Regs Proposed That Would Allow Temporary Lifts In Pools (Courtesy of Julie Mills)
Julie Mills, an attorney and blogger who writes about ADA issues in the hospitality industry, wrote a piece this week on HR 203 - a new bill that has been introduced in Congress that, if passed, would permit pools to use temporary lifts instead of incurring the expense and potential safety issues that arise from the ADA's current requirement for fixed lifts in most pools. Julie does a nice job of summing up the issue so, with her permission, I've reprinted her piece below. Julie's Blog, "The ADA: Titles II and III," can be found here.
(read her piece and my thoughts after the jump)
(read her piece and my thoughts after the jump)
Wednesday, January 2, 2013
Happy New Year From The California Supreme Court! A Home Run Ruling In Nalwa v. Cedar Fair
In the law, there aren’t many things that can rightfully be
called a home run. The vast majority of “big”
decisions out there are not total wins for one side, but are judged to be “big”
because, in the main, their result effects a shift in the law or undoes a prior
bad result even while, in some modest measure, containing a small victory for
the “loser.” The recent Supreme Court
Obama-care decision is a perfect illustration: the Court upheld the individual
mandate (the big win for liberals all over the country) while making clear that
the individual mandate is, in reality, a tax (a small victory for
conservatives). On New Year’s Eve,
though, the California Supreme Court issued a rare home run opinion in Nalwa
v. Cedar Fair – an opinion that eviscerates the prior poorly-reasoned decision
of the California Court of Appeals and unambiguously establishes the right of
amusement and recreation facilities to assert the primary assumption of the
risk defense to avoid costly and uncertain trial practice. Even more remarkable, although the decision
was a 6-1 majority (a strong victory to be sure), the Court of Appeals
reasoning – that California’s public policy precludes the applicability of the
assumption of the risk doctrine to the recreation industry entirely – was unanimously rejected. There is simply no way to view this decision as
anything but a complete home run for both Cedar Fair and the amusement industry
in general.
Thursday, October 4, 2012
3 Reasons To Be Optimistic For A Reversal In Nalwa v. Cedar Fair
Yesterday, October 3, 2012, the California Supreme Court heard argument in Nalwa v. Cedar Fair - a case I've already written about on a few occasions (like here, here, and here) and one the most closely-watched amusement industry cases in years. Due to the miracle of modern technology, I was able to observe the argument over the Internet and, while we will not know for about three months which way the Court is going to go, I am cautiously optimistic that the Supreme Court may reverse the Court of Appeals and hold that the primary assumption of risk doctrine may, in fact, be applicable to amusement park rides in California.Friday, August 31, 2012
Could the Disney Segway Issue Be Headed To The Supreme Court?
In my last post, I discussed Ault v. Walt Disney World Co., a class-action lawsuit in Florida challenging Disney's "no Segways" policy in its Florida properties. To quickly recap, the judge in Florida approved a settlement in the case finding that that Disney was likely to prevail under the ADA if the case actually went to trial because it could probably prove that Segways constituted an actual safety hazard in its parks.
Yesterday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit affirmed the trial court's ruling. Read more after the jump.
Yesterday, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit affirmed the trial court's ruling. Read more after the jump.
Labels:
ADA,
Ault,
Baughman,
California,
class certification,
disability,
discrimination,
Disney,
Disney World,
Disneyland,
guest service,
legislation,
litigation,
regulation,
Segway,
Walt Disney
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






